Search

Detailed search

Error report

processed

Cradle Song (Quentin)

Submitted by

artsinspired

On November 20, 2013

work

work

Cradle Song

Written by Charles H. Gabriel

Error description

Cradle Song


It took me a while to figure this out: work 47297 "Away in a Manger" appears twice, as an adaptation of "Luther's Cradle Hymn" (work 113948) and as an adaptation of Cradle Song" (work 113949) so the whole list of 311 entries appears twice on the page. I thought at first it was 2 lists reflecting the 2 major melodies used (the Mueller melody and the Kirkpatrick melody). Can we make it so the list just appears once?


Also, should the Kirkpatrick melody be its own work? It would be hard to separate out all 311 entries, and in some cases if we don't have access to a recording we wouldn't know which melody was used. So maybe for performances we know use the Kirkpatrick melody we should just note that in the comments section.


JoAnn

History

Comment by Quentin
2013-11-20 13:12:31 UTC

The hierarchy should be fine now.


As for the Kirkpatrick melody, it should definitely be its own work, if one or more of the 311 performances we have now in the database used the Kirkpatrick melody.


I'm pretty sure every performance I added used the Mueller melody, but of course I can't be sure about the performances added by other editors.

 
Comment by artsinspired
submitter
2013-11-21 01:25:08 UTC

Thanks for fixing the hierarchy. Definitely some of the 311 versions use the Kirkpatrick melody. Would you mind making a new entry for it? I'm a little confused about it.

 
Comment by Quentin
2013-11-23 14:25:28 UTC

Cradle Song [Kirkpatrick]

You can now move the performances that use the Kirkpatrick melody under this work.

I also added a comment here: Luther's Cradle Hymn

Hope it's a little clearer now.

 
Comment by artsinspired
submitter
2013-11-24 00:26:26 UTC

Thanks so much for taking care of this, Quentin.

 
Change by shs
2016-03-09 00:00:00 UTC
Conversion from forum topic to error report