Take a Giant Step (Canary)

Hello Snap,

The Monkees' version was indeed the first released version. However, the Rising Sons recorded it earlier and is thus considered as the original version according to the guidelines.

To keep it simple we usually take the first release of a song as the original.

Example: Big Yellow Taxi by Joni Mitchell is an original.

However, if it is known that before the first release it was recorded by another artist one should take the first recording by this other artist as original version.

Example: Although The Shadows released Apache before Bert Weedon, the original is attributed to Bert Weedon because he recorded it first

I also added most of the covers, except these (because of lack of information):

Take A Giant Step - Chic Lisitano [DROP THE SHOVEL]

Take A Giant Step - Tony Galla (of Rising Sons) [A.S.A.P. ]

Take A Giant Step Outside Your Mind - Vince Weber [THE BEST YET]

Snap, do you have some more info on these (release date, record company, year of release....)

Tony Galla's A.S.A.P. was released in 2001 according to AMG, though AMG does not list the credits. Tony Galla's website lists it as 1998. You can listen to a song sample which confirms it is the Goffin/King tune. http://www.tonygalla.com/disc.htm

Chic Lisitano released DROP THE SHOVEL in 2002 according to http://www.chicrocks.com/ . I don't have more information than that, I saw it for sale on eBay and the seller confirmed that it had the track "Take A Giant Step" and that it was by Goffin/King. Probably not enough info to add to the database.

I have the mp3 of Vince Weber (again, I know that's not enough). You can listen to a song sample at http://www.amazon.de/Best-Yet-Vince-Weber/dp/B00000ARIV . Accoring to Amazon, it was released in 1995.

DonNJ

Added the Tony Galla cover.

Unfortunately not enough info on the other 2.

Quote by Canary at 1174931918:

The Monkees' version was indeed the first released version. However, the Rising Sons recorded it earlier and is thus considered as the original version according to the guidelines.

Editor notes needed.

Done.

Entry update necessary here: Take a Giant Step

First release

On audio album Rising Sons Featuring Taj Mahal and Ry Cooder (1992)

Editor Notes

First recorded by The Rising Sons in 1966.

1992 is clearly not the first release + first recording should be set using database features.

Take a Giant Step also needs an update.

Did some corrections. Have a look at it.

Conversion from forum topic to error report