Search

Error report

processed

Old artists!

Submitted by

Mathieu

On February 20, 2011

Error description

Some artists are very old Wink


artist | birth_date | death_date | age | managed_by

Diane Tell | 0195-12-24 | | 1816 | Isa

David Jackson | 1047-04-15 | | 964 | baggish

John Hopkins Jr. | 1820-10-28 | 1991-08-14 | 171 | Quentin

Christina Rossetti | 1830-12-05 | 1984-12-29 | 154 | koan

Herbert Reynolds | 1867-01-01 | | 144 | Canary

Bob Haring | 1895-08-21 | | 116 | tsk

Kellie Pickler | 1896-06-28 | | 115 | Bastien

William Harris | 1900-01-01 | | 111 | anto47

Lil Johnson | 1900-01-01 | | 111 | tsk

Amidie Breaux | 1900-09-07 | | 111 | Canary

Tom Turner | 1901-01-01 | | 110 | Daniel

Domenico Titomanlio | 1901-02-16 | | 110 | nikitoz555

John Henry "Bubba" Brown | 1902-12-05 | | 108 | Daniel

Teddy Williams [1] | 1903-01-01 | | 108 | Daniel

Dick Robertson | 1903-07-03 | | 108 | Denis

Deadric Malone | 1903-11-01 | | 107 | Denis

Art Hodes | 1904-11-14 | | 106 | tsk

Mary Ellis | 1897-06-15 | 2003-01-03 | 106 | wally creek

Mager Johnson | 1905-12-07 | | 105 | Daniel

Margaret Adams | 1906-02-20 | | 105 | wally creek

Bill Jackson | 1906-02-22 | | 105 | Daniel

Walter Miller | 1907-01-01 | | 104 | Daniel

Red Nelson | 1907-08-31 | | 104 | Daniel

Bill Tapia | 1908-01-01 | | 103 | tsk

Marvin Johnson | 1908-12-17 | | 102 | Daniel

George Beverly Shea | 1909-02-01 | | 102 | hounddogman

Irving Berlin | 1888-05-11 | 1989-09-22 | 101 | Bastien

Johnny Messner | 1909-10-13 | | 101 | wally creek

Jimmie Davis | 1899-09-11 | 2000-11-05 | 101 | anto47

Robert Diggs | 1910-01-01 | | 101 | Daniel

Johnny Steggerda | 1910-01-01 | | 101 | Canary

Luke Jones | 1910-01-01 | | 101 | Daniel

Django Reinhardt | 1910-01-23 | | 101 | anto47

Johnny Lange | 1905-08-15 | 2006-01-06 | 100 | wally creek

Mary Lawlor | 1911-01-01 | | 100 | wally creek

Betty Hall Jones | 1911-01-01 | | 100 | Daniel

J.T. Adams | 1911-02-17 | | 100 | Daniel

Hy Zaret | 1907-08-21 | 2007-07-02 | 100 | Bastien


History

Comment by tsk
2011-02-21 04:24:04 UTC

To the best of my knowledge, Bill Tapia is still alive. I added the date of death for Art Hodes. The Comments for both Lil Johnson and Bob Haring both indicate that the respective artists are deceased, but date of death could not be established.

 
Comment by Isa
2011-02-21 11:04:20 UTC

Corrected my entry (Diane Tell).

 
Comment by hounddogman
2011-02-21 22:19:24 UTC

George Beverly Shea | 1909-02-01 | | 102 | hounddogman

=}


George Beverly Shea recently celebrated his 102nd birthday with a lifetime achievement Grammy for his gospel singing - and he still performs! Surprised

 
Comment by tsk
2011-02-22 23:06:48 UTC

Django Reinhardt's date of death added.

 
Comment by wally creek
2011-02-23 02:23:02 UTC

Perhaps it means we, being musically involved, will live very long lives, working on SHS in our dotage.


In consideration of having many inexact dates for birth/death, I can see why death dates are missing. Those inexact dates are NOT PERMITTED at SHS. And aside from name changes due to marriage/remarriage, more people disappear from public view than you think - ask any detective who specializes in missing person searches.


  • Just because there is no death date does not imply that the person is still alive. I really don't think people make this assumption.
  • Just because there is a death date but no birth date doesn't mean the person is living his life backwards.
  • Just because both dates are lacking doesn't mean the person does not exist, if you want to get ridiculous.
  • And so is the reported exact date correct under what criteria? Someone born June 22 at 1800 in Chicago was born on June 23 in European view. So who reported the date, where were they and how did they determine the date? And if you think this is trivial, you haven't seen enough reported release dates different by a day depending on where the reporter was.

I have checked my entries and stand by the dates given or have not found any additional data on the "open" artists.


koan's Christina Rossetti death date was a transcription error, now corrected.

Last updated by wally creek on 2011-02-23 02:33:01 UTC

 
Comment by baggish
2011-02-23 08:01:38 UTC

Updated David Jackson.

 
Comment by nikitoz555
2011-02-23 10:36:54 UTC

Domenico Titomanlio's birthday is correct, but nobody knows when he died.

 
Comment by Quentin
2011-02-23 17:33:15 UTC

Corrected John H. Hopkins Jr.


Jimmie Davis really died at the age of 101 (at least that's what official documents say).

 
Comment by Canary
2011-02-23 18:46:25 UTC

Adjusted my entries.

 
Comment by tsk
2011-02-24 00:58:13 UTC

While I certainly agree with Alan that the absence of a date of death may be for inability to verify as opposed too error or oversight, I though this posting did serve a useful purpose. It did lead to a number of corrections, including one of my entries and caused me to recheck if Bill Tapia was still alive. I think this type of posting is beneficial as an aid to protecting the integrity of the data.


Some would say I'm already in my dotage, but I'd take another 43, making me 100, dying over my keyboard, entering SHS data.

 
Comment by tsk
2011-12-07 21:45:55 UTC

Bill Tapia died one month shy of his 104th birthday a few days ago.

 
Comment by Denis
2012-01-06 17:11:04 UTC

Updated mine. We should better make this into an error list instead of a forum topic.


Created http://www.secondhandsongs.com/trac/ticket/1277

 
Change by shs
2016-03-09 00:00:00 UTC
Conversion from forum topic to error report