Search

Discussion

The case of the stolen melody ???????

jojo

New Editor
Posts: 1759

jojo @ 2014-10-10 14:38:06 UTC

"A Walk in the Black Forest by Horst Jankowski reached #1 on the US easy listening chart, #12 on the US Billboard Hot 100, and #3 on the UK Singles Chart, in 1965.


But how is it possible that the tune already appeared four years earlier in an Episode of Perry Mason TV series. And how is it possible that Barney Kessel was the conductor and wrote all the music for this Episode.

Did Horst lift it from Barney, or vice versa ?


Listen to the tune at 42 min and 57 seconds in the next YOUTUBE:




http://www.perrymasontvseries.com/wiki/index.php/EpisodePages/Show126



Jojo greets

Last edit: 2023-04-06 19:27:58 UTC by jojo

walt

Editor
Posts: 5782

walt @ 2014-11-28 17:39:34 UTC

Hahahahahaha... I think we're all fooled by someone who cleverly put that tune in the video. I doubt it's on the original release. But if it is ...


My best guess is that it might be a demo (no violins here) of "Eine Schwarzwaldfahrt" that got lost and wound up here ... after all, german Bert Kaempfert had become a big name in the US in 1960. Maybe Jankowski, 25 at the time, was trying to break in with a similar tune.


Anyway, the music doesn't sound anything Barney Kessel produced throughout that episode, so I'm pretty sure he didn't write it. I've seen no claims by him either.

jojo

New Editor
Posts: 1759

jojo @ 2023-04-06 19:17:40 UTC

Taken directly from an interview which Horst gave to WDR, a radio station in Germany.

"I had originally written that tune as "Eine Schwarzwaldfahrt" in 1961 for a radio show. It was a travel programme and I recorded a couple of tracks about famous places like, Paris, the Alps and that kind of thing. "Eine Schwarzwaldfahrt" was about a beautiful trip through Germany's Black Forest. It became successful in America first, in 1964, three years after I had recorded it. The whole story is a very unfortunate part of my career. In the sixties American producers were coming to Europe to buy music for TV shows."

"This was much cheaper for them than producing it at home since here they didn't have to pay musicians and the union. I sold them four tracks from the radio programme, including "Eine Schwarzwaldfahrt" and they paid me 125, - Deutschmarks, which seemed OK at the time. I signed a piece of paper and started work on something else. We musicians were pretty stupid back then. Not long after that, my song was used in an American TV show, and became a huge hit there under the title "A Walk in the Black Forest It was only then that I realised what exactly I had signed. I wouldn't get any royalties, all rights were owned by an American company. It took me seven years, several lawyers, and lots of money to get the rights back. After seven years, of course, the song was no longer a hit and didn't even make back the money I had spent on the lawsuit. Although I went on to sell lots of albums, I didn't make a penny from "Black Forest!"


http://forgottenhits60s.blogspot.com/2013/11/helping-out-our-readers-part-three-…


JoJo greets

Last edit: 2023-04-06 19:29:40 UTC by jojo

Tunesmith

Certified Contributor
Posts: 302

Tunesmith @ 2023-04-08 09:20:49 UTC

Nice piece of work, jojo. Case solved.